bought off ebay from good seller, correct details according to chassis etc
spent 1hr 30 faffing to get the bolts out, cursing the design of course

got new one out. oh dear was not heard. one bolt hole in different place, looking at it, seems the actual thermostat is only held in the housing by a spring lug on each side so think i will try swopping.
Why would they do this. Also . anyone else just swopped the thermo and kept same housing ?